🍷 FIELD NOTES FROM THE CAPE
Dispatches from our correspondent, who has been in the Winelands for three weeks and is running out of crackers
I Ordered the Wrong Wine with My Lamb Shank and I Will Never Fully Recover
Our reporter ventures into the Stellenbosch food and wine pairing scene and returns, technically unharmed, with notes
STELLENBOSCH — I want to begin by stating, for the record, that I am not an unintelligent person.
I have a university degree. I have successfully assembled flat-pack furniture on multiple occasions. I once navigated the entire Cape Town one-way road system without external assistance, which is an achievement the Western Cape Department of Transport should frankly be acknowledging with some kind of medal programme.
I ordered a Sauvignon Blanc with my lamb shank.
I know. I know.
In my defence — and I will be mounting a defence, because the alternative is accepting that one wine choice in a restaurant in Stellenbosch has structurally damaged my self-image — I was hot. It was a Wednesday. The Sauvignon Blanc was cold and the lamb shank was on the specials board and the connection between the two did not, in the moment, seem like the load-bearing decision it turned out to be.
The waiter’s face told me everything.
THE FACE
He did not say anything. This is important. What happened was entirely non-verbal — a masterpiece of micro-expression so finely calibrated that it communicated the complete situation without deploying a single word that could be repeated to a manager.
It began in the eyes. The very slightest contraction — not a wince, not a flinch, something far more controlled than either — the optical equivalent of a person hearing a small but incorrect note in a piece of music they know very well. Then the almost imperceptible pause before he wrote the order, during which I understood that the pause was not because he had forgotten his pen.
“The Sauvignon Blanc,” he said, writing it down.
“Yes please,” I said.
Another pause. Fractionally longer than the first.
“With the lamb shank,” he said. Not a question. A documentation of facts for the record.
“Yes,” I said, with the dwindling confidence of someone watching their own trial proceed.
“Of course,” he said.
Of course. Two words containing the entire history of incorrect wine and food pairing, delivered with the professional warmth of someone who has been trained, specifically, to make guests feel comfortable while simultaneously communicating that comfort is being extended across a gap that the guest should probably acknowledge.
He left. I sat with my decision. The Sauvignon Blanc arrived. It was cold and bright and crisp and entirely wrong for slow-braised lamb and I knew this now, knew it in the specific way you know something after it’s too late, which is the only way most of us ever really know anything.
THE SCENE
Stellenbosch has, over the past decade or so, developed a food and wine pairing culture of extraordinary sophistication and, if we’re being honest with each other in the way that good journalism requires, occasional intimidation.
The estates do it properly. The restaurants do it seriously. The sommeliers — and there are sommeliers everywhere in Stellenbosch, materialising at tables with the quiet inevitability of weather — do it with the kind of conviction that suggests they were born knowing that a mineral Chenin Blanc unlocks the specific fat content of a pan-fried linefish in ways that no other varietal can replicate.
They are not wrong. This is the maddening part. They are essentially never wrong. The pairing they suggest — the one they deliver with the quietly confident half-smile of someone offering you a gift they already know you’ll like — is always better than the pairing you’d have chosen independently. The Sauvignon Blanc with the linefish is extraordinary. The old vine Semillon with the mushroom risotto does do something that the risotto alone cannot do. The Reserve Pinotage with the short rib is the reason both things exist.
They’re right. The pairings are right. The micro-expressions are warranted.
This does not make the micro-expressions comfortable.
THE PAIRING MENU
Several Stellenbosch estates now offer formal pairing menus — tasting menus in which each course arrives with a specific, pre-selected wine, chosen by the winemaker or chef in consultation, designed to demonstrate the relationship between what’s on the plate and what’s in the glass.
I attended one.
Five courses. Five wines. One young woman explaining each pairing with the fluency and precision of someone who had clearly prepared and the genuine enthusiasm of someone who actually found the subject matter exciting rather than performative, which is the crucial distinction between good hospitality and theatre.
The first pairing: a compressed watermelon with fresh goat’s milk labne and a micro herb I couldn’t identify, paired with a 2023 Sauvignon Blanc. The wine lifted the acidity of the labne, she explained, while the residual sweetness of the watermelon found a mirror in the wine’s stone fruit notes. I tasted both together. Something happened that neither produced independently. I wrote “yes” in my notebook and underlined it twice.
The second pairing: a pan-fried Kingklip with fennel beurre blanc and pickled cucumber, paired with a barrel-fermented Chardonnay. The oak in the wine, she explained, echoed the slight char from the pan. The fennel’s anise quality found harmony with the wine’s toasty, almost caramel register. I tasted it. I closed my eyes. I opened them again. She was watching with the expression of someone who already knew.
“Yes?” she said.
“Yes,” I said.
By the fourth course — a braised lamb with roasted root vegetables and a jus made from the estate’s own Cabernet, paired with a seven-year-old Reserve Cabernet Franc — I had stopped trying to understand what was happening and simply accepted that I was experiencing something I couldn’t fully explain, which is the appropriate relationship with a very good pairing menu. You stop analysing and start receiving.
The fifth course was a dark chocolate fondant with a dessert wine that I would have described, before that evening, as too sweet, too rich, too much. With the chocolate, it was none of those things. It was the thing that made the chocolate make sense.
I told her this.
“That’s what it’s supposed to do,” she said.
THE S.N.O.B. TAXONOMY
Now. Let us be honest, because journalism requires it.
The pairing culture of Stellenbosch operates on a spectrum. At one end: the genuine, the curious, the deeply knowledgeable professional who has spent years thinking about the relationship between food and wine and who communicates that knowledge with warmth and the evident pleasure of someone sharing something they love.
At the other end: The Pairing Snob. A distinct and identifiable species.
The Pairing Snob does not correct you. The Pairing Snob is far too sophisticated for correction. The Pairing Snob has developed a communication system of such refined subtlety that the correction arrives without ever being issued, absorbed without ever being delivered, felt without ever having been said.
The Pairing Snob describes their recommended alternative to your chosen wine with an enthusiasm so precisely calibrated — so specifically warm, so individually addressed to you, so clearly sincere in its advocacy — that choosing your original wine after hearing it becomes an act of wilful self-deprivation that you commit against yourself entirely voluntarily.
You chose it anyway. Now you must live with it.
The Sauvignon Blanc with the lamb shank, it turns out, was not terrible. It was not the revelation that the recommended Grenache Noir would have been. It was a Sauvignon Blanc with a lamb shank, which are two perfectly good things that happened to share a table without having anything particular to say to each other.
Like a very pleasant dinner party where nobody quite connects.
Functional. Adequate. Missing the thing.
Next time I will order what they suggest.
I will order it confidently, as though it was my idea.
The waiter will know it wasn’t.
We will not discuss this.
The reporter’s Sauvignon Blanc was finished. The lamb shank was excellent. He ordered the recommended Grenache with his dessert, partly out of curiosity and partly out of remorse and it was completely wrong for a chocolate tart and he doesn’t care, the evening needed some chaos and the waiter’s face was absolutely worth it.
Be the first to comment